The purpose of this study is to use a new combination of anesthesia techniques in an attempt
to minimize early pain after surgery and improve the patient's ability to participate more
fully with physical therapy. Total knee replacement patients who participate will receive
the standard anesthesia. This includes a spinal nerve block as well as a femoral nerve
block. The study is looking at the added benefits of including an injection of numbing
medication (Bupivicaine) to the back of the knee. This injection occurs during surgery. In
order to compare the outcomes we will also have a group of patients who will receive a
saline injection as opposed to the numbing medication. Patients are randomly assigned to a
group. Outcomes are measured up until twenty-four hours following the surgery.
Purpose of Study This prospective, randomized, blinded controlled trial will be conducted to
evaluate post-operative pain control and physical therapy outcomes in primary total knee
arthroplasty (TKA) with the use of spinal analgesia and intra-operative posterior capsular
injections of ropivicaine 0.5% in conjunction with a continuous femoral nerve catheter.
We believe the results of this study will show an improvement in pain control and physical
therapy outcomes compared to traditional methods of analgesia in post-op total knee
arthroplasty. To the best of our knowledge, there are no studies in the literature using
this combination of femoral nerve analgesia and posterior capsular injection.
Certainly regional anesthesia methods such as femoral nerve blocks used alone or in
conjunction with sciatic nerve blocks have improved patient pain outcome measures in total
knee arthroplasty. Several studies have shown a beneficial effect of intra-articular
analgesia after capsular closure. We believe our study design will combine the beneficial
effects of the aforementioned methods, and ultimately improve patient pain, therapy effort,
and safety through less narcotic use.
Our goal is to share these results in a peer-reviewed journal, and at national orthopaedic
or anesthesia meetings. The data collected will ideally improve care and safety in the
post-operative total knee arthroplasty patient.
Background and Significance Post-operative pain control in total knee arthroplasty is an
area of great study in the orthopaedic surgery and anesthesia literature. The use of
spinal/epidural alone or in combination with regional anesthesia is well studied in the
recent literature. These techniques have significantly improved patient pain management,
physical/occupational therapy outcomes, and shortened time to discharge.
Additionally, intra-articular injection of local anesthetic after capsular closure has been
studied recently. Several studies have demonstrated a beneficial effect of intra-articular
local anesthetic on pain outcome measures (6, 8, 9, 10, 15). Although other studies have
reported more equivocal results. The impact of capsular analgesia has on post-operative pain
is intriguing. Decreased afferent pain perception by the capsular nerves from local
anesthetic may improve outcomes, especially in sensory distributions where regional
anesthesia is inadequate or not performed.
Much study has centered on regional anesthesia, specifically the use of single shot or
continuous femoral nerve blockade (4, 5, 11, 14, 16). Such studies have demonstrated a
statistically significant decrease in total narcotic use, sedation scores, and visual analog
pain scores. Femoral nerve blockade is now an accepted method of post-op pain control in
the total knee arthroplasty patient.
Further investigation has centered on the addition of sciatic nerve blockade to femoral
nerve block (1-3, 7, 12, 13). Several studies demonstrate a further improvement in pain
outcomes compared to isolated femoral nerve anesthesia. Sciatic nerve blocks can slow
physical therapy efforts secondary to a dense motor blockade. Equivocal results have been
reported in other studies due to this motor block, however, the sensory component appears to
provide improved pain outcome measures.
Femoral nerve blockade is a well-accepted modality for analgesia in total knee arthroplasty.
However, femoral nerve block alone does not provide adequate anesthesia to the posterior
aspect of the knee. We believe that intra-operative injection of ropivicaine 0.5% into the
posterior capsule will provide analgesia analogous to the sensory component of a sciatic
nerve block, while eliminating the limiting effects of the motor blockade. The combination
of femoral nerve block and intra-operative posterior capsular injection will ideally yield
improved pain management and physical therapy efforts above a baseline femoral nerve block.
Design and procedures This is a prospective double-blinded, randomized trial consisting of
two study groups: posterior capsular saline injection (control), and the experimental
posterior capsular ropivicaine 0.5% injection group. All patients will receive spinal
anesthesia and a continuous femoral nerve block. Each group will include 45 patients (n =
All patients will have an elective primary total knee arthroplasty performed. No revision
or bilateral cases will be included. Exclusion criteria will include patients with a known
allergy to ropivicaine or fentanyl, a known history of narcotic abuse or chronic pain, a
known diagnosis of peripheral neuropathy or complex regional pain syndrome, or a significant
impediment to physical therapy participation.
Following the informed consent process, patients will receive a continuous femoral nerve
block via catheter placed by experienced regional anesthesiologists at our institution.
Each patient will also receive spinal anesthesia for intra-operative pain control. A
standard midline skin incision with medial para-patellar arthrotomy will be performed
followed by implantation of either a Next Gen (Zimmer/Warsaw, IN), or Natural Knee II
(Zimmer, Warsaw, IN), or Posterior Femoral Component (PFC) Sigma (DePuy, Warsaw, IN) system.
Prior to surgery, patients will be randomized to the saline or ropivicaine groups. Both
groups will receive their respective injection prior to implantation of the components.
The posterior capsule of the knee will be divided in to four quadrants, each receiving a
saline or ropivicaine injection per randomization. Safety measures will include standard
pre-injection aspiration to check for vascular blush and intra-operative Doppler ultrasound
to identify vascular structures in the posterior knee. Additionally, the anesthesiologist
will not be blinded, as he/she will be responsible for assuring the appropriate medication
is used, and will be closely monitoring for cardiac arrhythmias in the unlikely event that
an intravascular injection occurs. Post-operatively, a standard bulky dressing will be
applied. All patients will be weight bearing as tolerated post-operative day 1. A fentanyl
PCA will be initiated in the PACU, and will be continued until post-operative day 2. Dosing
will be calculated based on lean body mass. Continuous femoral nerve blockade will continue
until post-operative day 2 as well.
Outcomes will include total PCA narcotic use, visual analog pain scale with a diagram to
localize pain, and Ramsey sedation scores. This data will be collected at the following
intervals: in the PACU, 4, 8, 12, and 24 hours post-operatively. We will also measure
post-operative day 1 knee range of motion, total ambulation distance, and time to straight
leg raise. A standard, Institutional Review Board (IRB) approved, data collection sheet will
We hypothesize that total post-operative narcotic use, visual analog pain scores, and Ramsey
sedation scores will be significantly lower in the study group (posterior capsular
ropivicaine 0.5% injection). Additionally, we anticipate the knee range of motion, total
ambulation distance, and time to straight leg raise to be significantly improved as well.
- The subject is scheduled to undergo elective total knee replacement at Duke
- The subject has signed the written consent form.
- Known allergy to ropivacaine or hydromorphone.
- Known history of narcotic abuse or alcohol abuse.
- Known history of chronic pain.
- Known diagnosis of peripheral neuropathy or complex regional pain syndrome.
- Significant impediment to physical therapy participation.
- The surgery is a revision case.
- Patient is undergoing bilateral Total Knee Replacement.